fb_px

Wives now get unearned benefits … Husband’s too!

October was not only the month for Halloween and Addams Family reruns, but also for new changes to North Carolina laws. I love thinking of the Addams Family as it parodies traditional family roles and makes me remember why I love all the quirky things about my family...
November 4, 2019

 

October was not only the month for Halloween and Addams Family reruns, but also for new changes to North Carolina laws. I love thinking of the Addams Family as it parodies traditional family roles and makes me remember why I love all the quirky things about my family and my clients’ families. I bet you can remember a funny scene from an Addams Family episode or movie right now without even trying.

October 1, 2019 saw some changes to the North Carolina laws regarding equitable distribution, specifically with regards to pensions. For this blog, N.C.G.S. §50-20.1(h) is amended so that the division of benefits applies to all vested and non-vested pension and retirement benefits. It went on to further define the benefits to include executive benefit plans, church plans, charitable organization plans, and IRAs. Traditional 401(k) and 403(b) as well as 457 accounts are still divisible.

Generally non-vested benefits were not divided because neither party actually owned the benefits. When something is not vested, there is a good argument that the ownership interest has not yet been created. For example, if you have a stock option that you cannot exercise until you have worked at your company for six (6) years, and it is only year three (3) of employment when you separate, then that option has in the past not been divided. It technically did not exist, it was more of a hope or wish that it would exist if everything went correct, the stars aligned, and you kept working at the same company.

However the winds are a changing. There are many, many different types of non-vested benefits which only vest with more work, bonus structures, or other actions which would happen after date of separation. Let’s examine for a moment how this might work. For example, both vested and non-vested stock options are often forms of executive benefits plans. If you are only married for 3 years, why should your spouse be entitled to benefits not accrued or earned on the date of separation? This is new territory folks. The argument on the other side is why should the spouse not be entitled to receive the three (3) years of value when/if they vest? Another good question.

Let’s be honest, it is also ripe for more costs to the client which they don’t need since attorney fees already eat away their estate. It is law changes like this that create so much expense for clients and increase attorney fees. Now a client will almost always need to hire an expert to value the interest that is non-vested. And just how do we value the marital interest of a non-vested stock option that may not be real, owned, or otherwise have value for years to come? Better yet, what about the malpractice of not valuing it when it becomes worth tens of thousands on the strike date?

New laws cost spouses more money for divorce

 

And even more, the language attorneys must draft into separation agreements between spouses becomes twice as important. Ensuring that the non-vested benefits may be obtained by the spouse when/if they become vested is a drafting nightmare of Addams Family proportions, without the humor that Fester Addams brings to the table.

So what does that mean for you? It means you must request and provide all non-vested benefits. This is vitally important in cases with non-vested retirement or pension plans, executive or unusual compensation plans, structured bonuses, and if paid commissions.

If you are not scared, well then you are either a seasoned divorce professional waiting for a new law to come out or (the more likely option) you have no idea what any of this means, do not own non-vested benefits, and wonder why I cannot find more child support or alimony things to write about! Touché … and in the memorable words of Wednesday Addams, “You might find a nice girl to be miserable with.”

Abandonment Addiction alientation Alimony Annesophia Richards Attorney Allie Moore Mediation auto appraisal Avoid Court Costs Bad behavior during divorce proceedings Benefits of Mediation Books Boundaries Breastfeeding business tax returns Cape Fear Family Law Mediation Certified Mediators Child Custody Child Custody Mediation Children Child Support child support modification Communication Community Assistance Conservatorship Conservatyorship Controlled Costs Cost-Effective Mediation Solutions Courtroom Absenteeism Custodial Exchange Custody discovery process Divorce Divorce and Your Business Divorce Arrangements Divorce Law Divorce Mediation Domestic Violence Equitable Distribution family businesses Family Dispute Mediation Family Law Family Law Mediation Faster Resolution Felony Stalking Finance Flexible Costs Foreclosures Government Assistance Grandparent Visitation harassment How Mediation Works in Family Law inappropriate comments litigation long-arm statute Long-Term Savings lower child support payments Lower Legal Fees Low Income Mothers Marital Estate Marital Property Mediation Follow-Up Mediation in Family Law Mediation Process Explained Mediation vs Litigation Medical Mental Health Messy Divorce Minimized Conflict Missed Doctors Appointments North Carolina Other Resources Parent Coordinator Parenting personal jurisdiction Post - Divorce Arrangements Post-separation Debts Private Investigators Property Distribution protective order rampant drug use Separation Separation Agreement skipping court dates Spiritual Assistance Starting Mediation Process Step Children Supervised Visitation Support Groups Unsolicited Phone Calls valuing cars Visitation waving attorney fee

Janet Gemmell
Practicing law for over 20 years may have caused Janet some gray hairs, but she remains young at heart, probably because she loves what she does. Janet's focus is to work with clients building new lives after relationship turmoil and although it is hard work, she finds it utterly rewarding. Such work and experiences gives Janet a ton of insight and along with her legal knowledge (afterall she is a Board Certified Family Law Specialist) she is able to get to the heart of any legal matter quickly in order to start helping clients find resolutions and to get their lives back on track.

Latest Blog Posts

Breaking Down a Messy Divorce – With a Side of Sanctions

When it came time to divvy up the marital estate, the judge made it clear that David’s antics had consequences

Courtroom Absenteeism – Not the Best-Strategy

Fairness is subjective when you’re not even in the courtroom to make your case.

Child Support INCREASED after 2 kids age out – Court of Appeals 2024

With no children born from the marriage but adult kids from previous ones, they quickly found themselves fighting over everything from houses to a boat

Crenshaw Child Support

The plaintiff’s subpoena attempts to delve into family business tax returns were promptly hit with a protective order

The Critical Importance of Discovery in Litigation

When you enter a legal dispute through the court system, both sides have a right to obtain information that supports their

Unsolicited Phone Calls Led to Felony Stalking in North Carolina

In this case, the victim, a 75-year-old widow, began receiving repeated, unsolicited phone calls from a fellow church member

Our Core Values

Knowledgeable

Knowledgeable

We know what to do and we actively share our knowledge.

Integrity

Integrity

Honesty in action and a good moral compass.

Empathetic

Empathetic

Active understanding without judgment.

Accountable

Accountable

To yourself, your clients, your colleagues and the court.